The short answer
iCloud encrypts your photos, yes. But by default Apple holds the keys, so the photos do not have end-to-end encryption. Apple can decrypt them, for example to help you get back into your account.
Turn on Advanced Data Protection and your trusted devices keep the keys. Then iCloud Photos have end-to-end encryption.
Apple holds the keys until you change that
Apple calls the default standard data protection. Apple encrypts your data on its way to iCloud and on its servers, but the keys sit in its data centers. That is why Apple can help when you set up a new device or forget your password.
Under this setting, 15 data categories use end-to-end encryption. Health data and the passwords in iCloud Keychain are two of them. Photos is not.
What Advanced Data Protection changes
With it on, the keys for most iCloud data stay on your trusted devices. The end-to-end categories grow from 15 to 25, and Photos, iCloud Backup, iCloud Drive and Notes join them.
The price is recovery. Apple cannot recover this data for you any more. If you cannot get into your account, you need one of 3 options. These are your device passcode or password, a person you named as your recovery contact, or a recovery key (a code of 28 characters). Set one up before you turn the feature on.
Your Apple Account also needs two-factor authentication. Every device that uses it must run current software. On iPhone, update to iOS 16.2 or newer.
- Open Settings and tap your name.
- Tap iCloud, scroll down, and tap Advanced Data Protection.
- Tap Turn on Advanced Data Protection and set up a recovery method.
Turn it on from one device, and it applies to the whole account.
What stays outside, even with it on
- Shared Albums and links that anyone with the link can open. Apple says these lack end-to-end encryption.
- A few details about your photos: a checksum of each item, whether it is a favorite, hidden or deleted, its dates, and how often you viewed it.
- Mail, Contacts and Calendar.
Access on iCloud.com is off while the setting is on. You can allow it again, and a trusted device must approve each temporary session.
Apple says that new users in the United Kingdom cannot turn on Advanced Data Protection any more. If you live there and have not turned it on, your photos stay under standard protection. Apple says the setting is still available in other regions.
Keeping some photos out of iCloud Photos
Advanced Data Protection protects the iCloud Photos library. It does not take a photo out of it. If a photo should not be in iCloud Photos at all, it needs a different home.
The vault has its own iCloud backup in your own iCloud storage, and that backup never holds the Secret Key. Apple can see that the backup exists, the number of items, their padded sizes and the dates of changes. If you lose your Apple Account, you lose that backup.
One step stays with you. Vault9 imports a photo from Photos but never deletes the original. Until you delete it, the original sits in the library under your iCloud setting. The guide on what syncs to iCloud has the details.
